RIGHTEOUS-RIGHT

Help one another in righteousness and pity; but do not help one another in sin and rancor (Q.5:2). The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. (Edmond Burke). Oh! What a tangled web we weave, When first we practice to deceive! (Walter Scott, Marmion VI). If you are not part of the solution …. Then you are part of the problem. War leaves no victors, only victims. … Mankind must remember that peace is not God's gift to his creatures; it is our gift to each other.– Elie Wiesel, Nobel Peace Prize Acceptance Speech, 1986.

Sunday, December 14, 2014

EAST PAKISTAN TRAGEDY: A DAILY DIARY

     Pakistan held General Elections in Dec. 1970, its first and fair since Independence under the scrutiny of military government of General Yahya Khan.
Total turnout of voting was 63.1% the highest turnout ever.
Awami League headed by Sheikh Mujibur Rahman won 160 seats (74.9%) in East Pakistan out of total allocation of 162 seats for East Pakistan.
Pakistan People Party headed by Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto won 81 seats (27%) out of total seats of 138 for West Pakistan.
PPP failed to win any seat in East Pakistan.
AL failed to get any seat from West Pakistan.
All leaders from West Pakistan, including PPP leaders, strongly resisted the notion of an East Pakistani-led government.
Bhutto voiced his infamous phrase, “Udhar tum, idhar hum” (there you, here me) – thus dividing Pakistan verbally. The same attitudes and emotions were expressed in East Pakistan.
Gen. Yahya convened National Assembly first session in Dacca on March 3, 1971.  Z.A.Bhutto and some rightist leaders denied to attend the N.A session in Dacca.
On 12 Jan. 1971, General Yahya Khan held a decisive meeting with Sheikh Mujib.  Sheikh Mujib was not prepared to concede an inch on any ground and the President closed the meeting in digust. He left Dhaka in anger and went straight to Larkana where he was hosted by Bhutto for two days. There they were joined by Gen. Abdul Hamid Khan. During the next two days, momentous decisions were taken about the fate of the country. A lot has been written about this meeting but it is all guess work. None is alive now and nothing on official records of their meeting proceedings.
During Jan. and Feb. 1971, Gen. Yahya had visualized the possibility of a military crackdown accompanied by the suspension of all political activity.  He therefore prepared a plan called Operation Blitz. It meant the suspension of all political activities in the country and a reversion of Martial Law rule in East Pakistan.  
Gen. Yahya backed up from convening National Assembly session in Dhaka and on 6th March he blamed Sheikh Mujib for the crisis by not allowing any concessions in his six points manifesto.
On 7th March the army was put on full alert to go into action in the event of Mujib’s declaration of Independence in his public speech.
On March 7, Mujib successfully contained in his public speech the pressure of the extremist wing of his party to announce Independence, and left the room of negotiations with Pakistan army open within the framework of united Paksitan (Stranger in My Own Country, by Lt. Gen. Khadim Hussein Raja).
Tikka Khan sent out to put down the unrest swelling in East Pakistan.
On 25th March Tikka Khan diected the brutal military crackdown (Operation Searchlight) with the help of Major Gen. Rao Farman Ali and other Army Generals that stunned the Bengalis with gross violence, atrocities and massive human rights abuses.
Lt. General Yaqub Khan, the then commander of East Command insisted that Gen. Yahya must not postpone the session of the National Assembly elected after the 1970 Elections. He insisted that the President should visit Dhaka in person at the earliest, and take decisions that only he could take.  Yaqub sent several messages, via telephone and in writing but President was not convinced tht his presence would help. Gen. Yaqub informed to Peerzada, the personal secretary of the President, that since the President’s visit did not materialize, he was unable to carry on with his responsibilities; he was resigning from his post, and that the written resignation would be communicated on the morning of 5th March, 1971.[1]
Gen. Niazi was sent to Dhaka to replace Gen. Yaqub Khan and he took the command of East Pakistan. 
Hartal and boycott started countrywide March 7, countrywide on call from Awami League. Mujib house in Dhanmandi, Dhaka, became the focal point of all political activities and Awami League high command went into round-the-clock session there. Responsibilities were delegated for all functions of the government including the public utility services, banks, transportation and the information media.  Even the buses and railway trains were left at wayside stations where they were deserted by their staff.  The Dhaka airport staff also went on strike and disappeared.  The unity of action and purpose demonstrated by the entire province was surprisingly complete.  The Martial Law Administrator, at this stage, was left with no one to answer his commands, except his troops.  In fact, it seemed obvious that on a clarion call from Sheikh Mujib, they would even take up arms in his support.
However, with every passing day Awami Leave tightened its grip on the administration in East Pakistan.  All organs fo the government reported to Sheikh Mujib's headquarters for instructions.  Even Inspector General of Police stopped coming to Martial Law headquarters, but started reporting to Sheikh Mujib’s residence.  Sheikh Mujib had, in the meantime, announced that he would address a public rally at the Ramna Race Course on 7 March 1971 at 4 p.m.
Tikka Khan had settled down for barely a weekwhen President Yahya Khan arrived on 15 March  He called fact finding conference the evening he arrived.  He was explained the details of the prevailing situation.  On 16 March, he went into negotiations with Sheikh Mujib.
“At about 10 p.m. on 17 March, Tikka Khan informed Maj. Gen. Ferman, Gen. Abdul Hamid Khan and me that the negotiations with Sheikh Mujib were not proceeding satisfactory and the President, therefore, wanted us to be ready for military action and to prepare a plan accordingly.  No further verbal or written directions were issued.
On the morning of 18 March, Farman and I assembled in my office to work on the plan.  Short of time, we agreed on the broad details of the plan. The President had his own plan—to flee from Dhaka prior to the military action.”[2]   
“On 21 March Mr. Bhutto arrived with his party advisers and lieutenants and joined negotiations with Sheikh Mujib which reportedly failed.  On failure of negotiations, he returned to West Pakistan safely.
The new plan, prepared by Farman Ali and me was named ‘Searchlight’.  I was instructed to put Operation Searchlight into action on the night between 25 and 26 of March 1971.  This was a momentous decision and I was very sad for the country.  The President had apparently decided to dump East Pakistan and let it go its own way. He seemed to be concerned about his personal safety only. Therefore, he left Dhaka under some sort of a cover plan at about 7 p.m. on 25th March, which fooled nobody except, probably, himself.”[3]
After disarming of almost all centers of the East Pakistan Rifles, elements of the East Bengal Regiment and the Reserve Police, the Pakistan Army, in collusion with religious extremist razakars of Al-Badr and Al-Shams, engaged in the systematic genocide and atrocities of Bengali civilians, particularly nationalists, youth and religious minorities.[4]  Neighboring India provided economic, military and diplomatic support to Bengali nationalists.  Bangladesh government-in-exile was set up in Calcutta.  Mujib was arrested and flown to West Pakistan.  Most of the Awami League leaders fled and set up a government-in-exile in Calcutta, declaring Bangladesh an independent state.
The civil was created a widespread displacement of civilians in East Pakistan and widespread violations of human rights – carried out by the Pakistan Army with support from political and religious militias, beginning with the start of Operation Searchlight on 25th March 1971.  Independent researchers put the toll at 300,000 to 500,000.  A further eight to ten million people fled the country to seek safety in India.[5]  Bangladeshi sources cite a figure of 200,000 women raped, giving birth to thousands of war babies.[6]
Wary of the growing involvement of India, the Pakistan Air Force launched a pre-emptive strike, called Operation Chengiz Khan,  on Indian Air Force planes on the ground.  The strike was seen by India as an open act of unprovoked aggression.  This marked the official start of the Indo-Pakistan War.  Three Indian corps was involved in the liberation of East Pakistan.  They were supported by nearly three brigades of Mukti Bahini fighting alongside them, and many more fighting irregularly.
This was far superior to the Pakistani army of three divisions.  The Indians quickly overran the country selectively engaging or bypassing heavily defended strongholds.  Pakistani forces were unable to effectively counter the Indian attack, as they had been deployed in small units around the border to counter guerrilla attacks by the Mukti Bahini.  Unable to defend Dhaka, the Pakistanis surrendered on 16 December 1971.[7]
On 16 Dec. Lt. Gen. A. A. K. Niazi, CO of Pakistan Army forces located in East Pakistan signed the Instrument of Surrender.  Over 93000 Pakistani troops surrendered to the Indian forces, making it the largest surrender since World War II.
To ensure a smooth transition, the Simla Agreement was signed in 1972, between India and Pakistan.  The treaty ensured that Pakistan recognized the independence of Bangladesh in exchange for the return of the Pakistani 93000 PoWs.[8]
For full episodes of Army actions, failure of political negotiations, faulty political decisions of the leadership of Pakistan Peoples Party, and for fact finding search, it is highly recommended to read through the pages of Hamoodur Rahman Commission Report.

ISRAR HASAN
14 Dec. 2014



[1] Lt. Gen. Khadim Hussein Raja; “Stranger in My Own Country”; p.57
[2] Ibid. Khadim Hussein Raja; p.71.
[3] Ibid. p.79.
[4] “Leading News Resource of Pakistan”, Daily Times, May 17, 2010; and GenocideBangladesh.org.       Retrieved Dec. 14 2014.
[5] Rummel, Rudolph J., “Statistics of Democide: Genocide and Mass Murder Since 1900” Chap.8, Table 8.2 Pakistan Genocide in Bangladesh Estimates, Sources, and Calculations.
[6] Menen, Aubrey (23 Jul.1972). “The Rapes of Bangladesh”, The New York Times.
[7] Encyclopedia Wikipedia, Chap. Bangladesh Liberation War 1971.
[8] Ibid.

No comments:

Post a Comment